by

September 7, 2012

Clarence-Stukes-Hmpg

Photo: Steve Thurston

Arlington Public Schools Assistant Superintendent of Facilities and Operations answers questions outside the school board meeting. Many parents have complained about a newly-enforced busing plan, but Stukes believes it is fundamentally sound.

In a sign that the school busing debate may not be letting up anytime soon, about a dozen parents spoke to the school board last night, demanding changes to a system they called a “sham” and a “failure,” brought to them by school staff that were “arrogant and rude.”

“Please know that we do hear you, and the Arlington Public School staff hears you,” replied APS board Chair Emma Violand-Sanchez after the end of public comment. Many parents at the back of the room shook their heads and made disbelieving remarks.

Reading from a prepared statement, Violand-Sanchez said, “So, as you’re well aware, it was with the goals of greater efficiency, safety, and timeliness, that changes to our transportation were undertaken. But, as many of you have fairly pointed out, we may have missed those marks in some cases.” She promised that the discussion would continue.

One mark that may have been missed or not--depending on which side is asked--was the public vetting of the plan. Staff maintained throughout the night that they had kept the community informed. The planning has been conducted over the past year with reports to the board. It was presented to the school board in June, staff said. PTAs were notified.

However, there was no public comment period, no official time for parents to say their peace before the plan was implemented.

“We’ll accept that criticism,” said Clarence Stukes, the assistant superintendent for facilities and operations who has been overseeing the changes.

“The depth of the [implemented] changes was something that was not fully realized" in June, said board member Sally Baird after the board meeting. She added, “I think we all wish it had gone a little differently.”

The issue began about three weeks ago when APS sent letters home to some parents explaining that their children who may have been riding a bus to school in previous years now would be required to walk, ride a bike, or find another way to school. Another 14,000 letters were sent to other parents telling them that their children were allowed to ride the bus. Those letters contained a bus pass.

The rule said that any elementary school student who lives within a mile of the school must walk, and any middle or high schooler must walk if he or she lives within 1.5 miles of the school.

The plan did not take roadways into account. Some students have to cross some of Arlington’s busier roads. Parents have been concerned about safety and about the timing of the announcement, coming after they had made daycare and afterschool arrangements.

by

September 7, 2012

Do you like this?

Comments (12)

Comment Feed

Something is rotten in Dennmark

another one bites the dust!

I just read an article about how the Assistant Superintendent for Instruction (Dr.Karen Sanchez-Griego ) who was announced in the job June 19th is no longer at that job and that the retired Assistant Superintendent for Administration is the acting Assistant Superintendent . The interesting part is that Dr.Sanchez is the second person that takes that job this year that is no longer in it!

Here is the article :http://www.sungazette.net/arlington/news/assistant-superintendent-returns-in-interim-capacity/article_718ec128-0316-11e2-ae39-0019bb2963f4.html.
Something is going on "up there " at the helm of APS!

jonathan 243 days ago

Here's what they value more than our students

As an insight into the mindset of the Superintendent and School Board who unilaterally stripped school bus transportation from 1500 Arlington public school students, here's a beautiful quote from Arlington County School Board member James Lander's Twitter and Facebook pages:
June 19 via Twitter,‎"3 Things that are absolutely worth spending more money, real estate, toilet paper, and legal representation...!"
So, Mr Lander, how about adding getting kids to school safely and ready to learn. How about those preschoolers who can no longer participate in their school breakfast program because they don't have transportation to school. How about parents who have to shell out $5000 per year now for extended day care at school. How about parents who have had to cut or shift their work hours to get their children to school.





Board Members, please wise up! 244 days ago

Didn't they check with Child Protective Services

Note that according to Arlington County Human Services website, no child 8 years or younger can be left unsupervised at home, in their yard or in a playground - and yet School Superintendent Murphy and the School Board decree that these children walk 1 mile to school. Also according to the County Human Services website the minimum appropriate age for a babysitter is 13 years. This means that there is no elementary child old enough to supervise or escort children 3rd grade and younger any distance, let alone on a one mile trek to school. Parents need to be reminded that if not bussed young children must be driven or escorted by an adult or by a child old enough for 8th grade! If Child Protective Services are called they will have to respond, and parents will end up in court.

School Board guilty of irresponsible child endangerment 247 days ago

Not Too Late

The sooner the Board realizes that supporting the mangled implementation of a deeply flawed plan that -- at its core -- was a series of lies and disinformation to cover up the resource needs of a growing County, the better. The Board and Super need to stop combatting concerned parents and citizens and start work NOW to regain the public trust they have lost over this debacle. Giving Transportation Services support is a mistake --they are understaffed and undertrained and too entrenched in protecting themselves from the bad PR that comes with their bad and dangerous plan to get this fixed. How long before children are injured because you have turned a deaf ear on the public that trusts you to listen and do right? Listen School Board, you are elected to ensure SAFE education for the children of this County--and throwing 1000 children off buses by fiat and onto busy crowded roads who have never been there before is a dangerous lapse in your judgement. The public needs to hear YOU put a halt to this bad plan. Stop hiding behind efficiency and GPS and "data." We're all much more interested and willing to keep digging than you think. If this is a resource issue, than don't hide that from the voters. If you want to stop busing in North Arlington in places that have had busing for literally decades, that's an issue that belongs squarely in a public debate. No one elected you to choose and back a Superintendent who puts "data driven efficiency" over child safety.

Arlington Voter 257 days ago

So much for journalism ethics....

Hope you teach your students better. I don't understand why you don't state - in every article on this topic - that your family is directly affected by the change in walk zones.

A neighbor 258 days ago

Seriously?

It is disingenuous for APS to say they worked with PTA’s. In June, they revealed that change was coming, asked for PTA’s to advise their communities that change was coming and indicated the plan was getting ready for roll out. IN JUNE. There were no particulars shared. That was the last and ONLY discussion that APS had with PTA’s. There was no collaboration, no discussions of safety plans, no plans for changes to Kiss and Drop rules, as they have claimed. And the engagement of the police force to bring attention to school age pedestrians? A joke. Parking flashing speed signs in front of schools for one week isn’t going to help or change anything.

Feigning Shock 258 days ago

Confused and upset

I know jamestown and Taylor elementary schools also have bus stops under a mile and even less than 1/2 of mile from school. The bus stop by our house is still there but we can't take it while homes closer to the school where Kids do not have to cross a busy or dangerous street are given bus service. There is a lot wrong with this plan but the unfairness against some is appalling. It has been reported that about 1500 students have lost bus service but APS added about 1000 new students. This shows that buses should have extra space, but that is not happening as my child's bus is overcrowded. This leads to the conclusion that they have reduced the number of buses in a year that APS new the population was growing. Why is APS hiding bus routes and any facts about this plan? It seems that is not about safety it is about hiding there devious plan and the discrimination they are foisting on unsuspecting parents.

Parent voter 258 days ago

Child Endangerment

What is needed is a veteran reporter on the case to look into what's been going on behind the scenes of this story. It's a scandal for sure. Getting rid of these folks via the ballot box will take place just as soon as possible and Murphy and Stukes will almost certainly end up fired over this craziness--eventually. There is simply no way this plan can be left in place day after day, week after week, month after month without some young person being mangled or worse. They are playing high stakes poker here on the backs of this community. Somewhere out there there must be one hell of a payoff. It's an ugly story just waiting for a real reporter to tackle it.

Something Rotten in the State of Denmark 258 days ago

Only What We Deserve

They would not have DARED enact that terrible transportation plan if there were a non-Democrat on the ballot.

Jerry 258 days ago

There was no listening

The APS Board did not listen - they sat there and waited until they could give their canned response. They are useless and clearly care nothing for student safety or for the families in the APS system. As for Stukes - for him (or anyone) to characterize this mess APS calls a transportation plan as 'sound' shows just how ignorant they are. Beyond having no expertise in this area, they clearly have absolutely no knowledge of what a transportation plan even entails. Stukes and Murphy should be fired. They tried to pull a fast one on APS parents, again clearly demonstrating a complete lack of understanding of basic planning principles.

Tired of APS 258 days ago

Elimination of school bus routes for APS

If the measurement of distance from ones school is from the property line of a students residence to the closest property line of the school. Then I ask that all of the APS school buses drop all APS students off at the closest property line of their school. I know I’d feel a lot better if all those bus riders got a little exercise walking from the school property line to the school entrance.

On another note there are many students who are in the “walk zone” of their school & their bus routes have not been eliminated. Barrett is one example, as well as students at ATS, I have heard that Alcova Heights still has busing to Barcroft. There are probably other examples across the county, if you do enough research. I wonder why the rule of 1 mile in an elementary zone & 1 1/2 miles in a secondary zone doesn’t apply to everyone.

Just a Thought 258 days ago

Elimination of school bus routes for APS

It would take a brave man and a true leader to just come out at this point and admit that, as well intentioned as folks may have been in implementing this plan, serious mistakes were made that are putting area students at risk Monday through Friday and possibly endangering their parents' employment and peace of mind.

I'd have respect for Dr. Murphy and the School Board members if they were able to put their own personal considerations aside and put a halt to this reckless plan with an eye to coming back to more sensible, community-driven reforms in future. That would require honesty, courage, and real sense of stewardship.

What's going on here is just plain wrong and asking rational adults to condone the plan as is is nothing short of offensive. Surely, the Superintendent and the School and County Boards must know this by now. The matter is far too urgent to be delayed.

I continue to be dismayed by the stubborn insistence of refusing to consider group, neighborhood appeals. Surely this would be a central feature in any competent and responsible reform.

Maria Ballantyne 258 days ago

Support the Merc! Donate Now!
Learn media production. Engage your community.

May

Click the links below to learn what we're up to and how you can support us. Thanks!
Sample Right Image Teaser